Anthropology of victim in postmodern cultural practices

Authors

  • O. A. Pushonkova Bohdan Khmelnytsky National University of Cherkasy image/svg+xml

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17721/UCS.2021.2(9).14

Keywords:

victim anthropology, cultural archetypes, sacrifice, victimhood, psychology of aggression, narcissism, escapism, cultural-traumatic discourse

Abstract

The article examines the anthropological dimension of the victim phenomenon through the prism of Rene Girard's concept and modern studies of nihilistic tendencies of cultural scenarios with dominant polar psychotypes. The significance of Rene Girard's theory in the study of the archetypal basis of victim behavior, its historical sources and myth-ritual basis is studied. The cultural specifics of modern forms of counteracting victimhood and value contradictions of the victim's figure in the conditions of new threats to humanity, changes in the space of culture in the direction of increasing dependence on media communication platforms, are revealed. Some aspects of the victim's behavior have been linked to identity patterns which suggests a hedonistic-entertaining culture format that results in narcissistic choices or escapist behavior. The article clarifies the nature of the interaction between the images of the victim in the era of multimedia communication and cultural practices which acquire the character of a ritual response to the archaic internal conflict in the context of cultural-traumatic discourse.

Examining the sacred nature of the victim in the processes of desacralization of modern culture, according to R. Girard, preservation and essential transformation of this defining archetype as a medium of aggression is concluded.

In the modern scenarios a model of total victim is formed that has lost the function of channeling social aggression, falling into a vicious circle of destruction of either oneself or others (W. Kraus), or which is "stuck" in the "triangle of fate", where everyone is a victim (S. Karpman).

A hedonist who suffers from shortcomings in a flat everyday life, having lost the tragedy of his own existence in the culture, acts as its repressed subject, but is not aware of it, according to the psychoanalytic theory of cultural trauma. However, in everyday practices (bullying, gaslighting, trolling) anyone can be a victim at any time. In a more global dimension, we are talking about the collective nature of sacrifice, as evidenced by the tendencies of radicalism, terrorism, war, genocide, etc.

It is possible to eliminate human inherent aggressive instincts only through the step-by-step development of the value sphere (W. Kraus). This is the only thing that can prevent the self-destruction of the mankind and solve the problem of intraspecific aggression, which was considered from different points of view by K. Lorentz and R. Girard.

References

Александер Дж. Культурная травма и коллективная идентичность / Дж. Александер // Социологический журнал. – 2021. – № 3. – С. 6–40.

Геннеп А. ван. Обряды перехода. Систематическое изучение обрядов / А. ван Геннеп. – М: Издательская фирма "Восточная литература" РАН, 1999. – 198 с.

Жирар Р. Козел отпущения / Пер. с фр. Г. Дашевского; Предисл. А. Эткинда / Р. Жирар. – СПб.: Изд-во Ивана Лимбаха, 2010. – 336 с.

Жирар Р. Насилие и священное / Р. Жирар. – СПб.: Новое лит. обозрение, 2010. – 448 с.

Зыгмонт А., Дюков Д. Философия насилия и сакрального Жоржа Батая и Рене Жирара в сравнительной перспективе [Електронний ресурс] / А. Зыгмонт, Д. Дюков. – Режим доступу: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/filosofiya-nasiliya-i-sakralnogo-zhorzha-bataya-i-rene-zhirara-v-sravnitelnoy-perspektive/viewer

Кайуа Р. Миф и человек. Человек и сакральное / Р. Кайуа. – М.: ОГИ, 2003. – С. 83–104.

Краус В. Нігілізм сьогодні, або Терплячість світової історії / Перекл. з німецької М. Павлюка / В. Краус. – К.: Основи, 1994. – 124 с.

Лоренц К. Оборотная сторона зеркала / Пер с нем. А. И. Федорова; Под ред. А. В. Гладкого; Сост. А. В. Гладкого, А. И. Федорова; Послесл. А. И. Федорова / К. Лоренц. – М.: Республика, 1998. – 393 с.

Маффесоли М. Околдованность мира или божественное социальное [Електронний ресурс] / М. Маффесоли. – Режим доступу: http://www.gumer.info/bibliotek_Buks/Sociolog/Article/Maff_OkMir.php

Мосс М., Юбер А. Очерк о природе и функции жертвоприношения / М. Мосс, А. Юбер // Мосс М. Социальные функции священного: Избр. произведения; пер. с франц. под общ. ред. И. В. Утехина. – СПб.: Евразия, 2000. – С. 7–103.

Тэрнер В. В. Символ и ритуал / В. В. Тэрнер. – М.: Наука, 1983. – 277 с.

Published

2021-12-28

Issue

Section

APPLIED CULTURAL STUDIES

How to Cite

O. A. Pushonkova. 2021. “Anthropology of Victim in Postmodern Cultural Practices”. Ukrainian Cultural Studies 2 (9): 83-87. https://doi.org/10.17721/UCS.2021.2(9).14.